Advertisement

About Me

Gwenn Schurgin O'Keeffe, MD, FAAP

This Just In: Our Kids Are Really Not That Fit!

If you ask parents if their kids are fit, most will say “yes”. If you ask kids if they are fit, most think they are. A new study out tomorrow in JAMA rocks those perceptions to the core with quite a reality check. (JAMA. 2008;300[3]:295-305.)

The recommended amount of activity to stay healthy and avoid things like obesity  is 60 minutes a day for kids.  This doesn’t have to occur all at once but over the course of the entire day. Recess counts. Gym counts. Running outside after school – counts. How many kids are meeting this mark? That is just what  researchers out of UC San Diego wanted to know, and the results  shock you.

The researchers followed 1000 kids ages 9-15 who wore a special belt called a accelerometer to monitor their physical activity levels 1 week a year at ages 9, 11, 12, and 15.  Most kids met the guidelines at ages 9 and 11 - good news so far. However, by age 15, less than 1/3 were getting the recommended amount of exercise!  Girls started to dip in their activity around age 13 years of age and boys around age 14.7.

Despite a few limitations with the study, which all studies have, the results are a big wake up call for all of us that  our kids' future healths are at huge risk! If you take a moment to look around your community, you'll know what I mean. It is like a switch gets tossed between tweendom and teendom and sets a ball in motion that doesn't bode well for what these kids will be like as adults. As stated in the study's conclusion:  

“This decrease [in physical activity] augurs poorly for levels of physical activity in U.S. adults and potentially for health over the course of a lifetime. Consequently, there is a need for program and policy action as early as possible at the family, community, school, health care, and governmental levels to address the problem of decreasing physical activity with increasing age.”

Programs are a great idea but those will take time to develop and implement. While that process is ongoing, there is a great deal you can do to improve your family's physical activity amount and, consequently, future health: 

1. Get everyone moving more each and every day. Make it a family affair. In my family, we take a walk together at some point around dinner time. Start small and build from there. Small changes over time tend to be the ones with the biggest long term benefits - and the ones that create the best life-long habits. 

2. Hunt for activities your kids can have fun with as kids but that will carry over into adult life. These tend to be the more individual sports. Team sports are fantastic but most kids won't carry those over beyond childhood.

3. Carve out time for free play as often as possible. Old fashioned outdoor fun with no game plan will let you kids burn off steam daily as well as fill an important developmental and emotional need.

Finally, this study puts the recent debate of Statin drug use in kids in a very different light.  As I wrote recently, I'm ambivalent about the use of Statins in kids. The risk/benefit analysis seems shaky to me, as well as to many of my pediatric colleagues. It is hard to recommend a pill for a child in that setting. But, now that we know kids are not moving enough, we can't count on that to keep cholesterol in check either.  Talk about a catch-22! It may very well be that until we get kids more active, Statins are our only alternative for some kids - emphasis on some!  

So, with the Statin recommendation lurking in the wings and this new JAMA study opening our eyes on how much kids are really moving as they become teenagers, what now? Do as they do in the Madagascar movie, just move it! 

5
Average: 5 (1 vote)

one more reason why cutting

one more reason why cutting kids from sports programs is a TERRIBLE idea...anyways, I just wanted to say that when I grew up, in my school there was always the fat kid, however, when I look at youth these days, it seems as though half of the kids are obese or on the path to obesity! and I was in grade school only a little over a decade ago! Now, to generalize from my personal observations would be wrong, but this is what I'm seeing more and more, little kids who are really fat. Furthermore, in my age group (23-26) I am noticing more and more of my peers becoming overweight individuals, many of whom were once athletes! This is disturbing for many reasons.

You are right...all of society is unfit

Taylor:

Thanks for your comments. Your observations are right on the mark. As a society, health and fitness are spiralling out of control. More people than not feel like you do about having trouble finding a sport or workout plan that is fun and reasonable to do but unlike you most people don't keep trying or make it an effort. The sad truth is that for people overweight, they have to find a way to get fit even if it isn't fun at first - and it won't be. It will be work until they get in shape and are able to move their bodies a bit more easily. However, if they work with someone empowering, they will get their and find the ride has been worth it.

I have observed this trend daily

Yes, athletics and sports participation are great ways to stay in shape, however, the best avenue to treat the masses is through physical education class.

I have seen this trend of overweight kids gradually increasing over the last 4 decades and I have been teaching in 3 of these decades. Illinois is the only State left with mandatory PE through high school and even here the implementation is not at the level of where it should be to combat this trend. Especially at the younger ages where interest is high and life long habits can be developed. It will take a great deal of effort and attitude change to make a positive impact. Many see physical education as a low priority in schools and do not truly understand the far reaching benefits of a well designed program from kindergarten through high school, nor the implications from cutting good programs or from poorly designed ones. One of the many far reaching benefits, aside from the obvious physical ones, includes the new brain research that supports the idea of kids doing better in school when their intellectual education is preceded by activity, especially aerobic activity, and their general state of physical fitness is at high levels. Here is a statement from our new curriculum guide to be implemented next school year. This statement was based off of much of the new brain research available today:

*There is also a proven link between greater cardiovascular conditioning and higher mental capacity. This greater mental capacity is due to the release of exercise induced endorphins, hormones, and enzymes that promote brain function. On the most basic level, you are increasing blood flow to the brain and providing it with the max amount of fuel, oxygen, and enzymes to work at an optimal level.*

There is so much that I could write on this topic I am not sure of where to start so let me just say that I believe the solution lies much more with our school systems physical education programs, and the attitudes our society has about them, than with anything else.

Kirk Mango
Becoming a True Champion

I echo Kirk's sentiments.

I echo Kirk's sentiments. Bring back gym classes. Let's face it, kids in that 13-17 age group you are your typical rebellious kid. They've learned in health class that they need to stay fit and the importance of it, but kids don't listen at that age. Many are conscious of their bodies and of course we don't want to sweat, mess up our hair, etc.

We need to mandate gym class for these kids. Get them doing something. For many in this age group, it's get up, go to school, sit around all day, go home, talk on the phone or play video games, go to bed and repeat the next day.
And we wonder why there is an obesity problem.
I do not go with the next leap and say this is a reason not to cut from sports progams, two totally different things. Start and intramural program for the kids that maybe don't want to commit to practicing a sport everyday. At least they are active.